/ Blog
Home Blog Contact Buddy Ads Builder Audit Engine

Need advice on which bidding strategy to use for Google ...

Bidding & Smart Bidding

Match your bidding strategy to your conversion data volume. Use Manual CPC while gathering data (<20 conversions/month), shift to Maximize Conversions at 20–30 monthly conversions, then add a Target CPA once you have 4–6 weeks of observed CPA data. For ecommerce, move to Maximize Conversion Value with a Target ROAS after 50+ monthly conversions with revenue values passing through.

Key takeaways

  • Smart Bidding strategies require sufficient conversion history to function — launching Target CPA on a new campaign with no data produces expensive, unreliable results.
  • The practical bidding ladder is: Manual CPC → Maximize Conversions → Maximize Conversions with Target CPA → Maximize Conversion Value with Target ROAS.
  • Set your initial Target CPA at or above your observed average CPA, then reduce it gradually — starting too low starves the campaign of impressions.
  • Brand and non-brand keywords should always live in separate campaigns under separate bidding strategies, regardless of which strategy you use.
  • Every strategy switch triggers a learning period of 1–4 weeks; avoid making additional changes during this window or you will reset the clock.
Key terms
Smart Bidding
Google's auction-time automated bid strategies — including Maximize Conversions, Target CPA, and Target ROAS — that use machine learning to optimize bids toward a conversion goal.
Target CPA
An optional target added to Maximize Conversions that tells the algorithm to seek conversions while averaging toward a specified cost-per-conversion over time.
Target ROAS
An optional target added to Maximize Conversion Value that instructs Google to optimize bids for revenue return, expressed as a percentage of ad spend.
Learning Period
A temporary phase of 1–4 weeks after a bidding strategy change during which Google's algorithm recalibrates, often causing performance fluctuations before stabilizing.
Portfolio Bid Strategy
A shared bid strategy that pools conversion data from multiple campaigns, allowing accounts with individually low conversion volume to meet Smart Bidding data thresholds collectively.

Which bidding strategy should you start with on a new campaign?

Start with Manual CPC when you have no conversion history — it keeps you in control while the account builds the signal Smart Bidding needs to function. This question comes up regularly in the r/PPC community, and the core disagreement usually traces back to practitioners skipping this phase. [1]

If your primary week-one goal is traffic volume — to test landing pages or understand search behavior — Maximize Clicks with a hard maximum CPC cap is a reasonable alternative. Without the cap, Google will freely spend on tangentially related terms at whatever click price it deems appropriate.

Common Mistake: Launching a brand-new campaign with Target CPA or Target ROAS. Without conversion history, the algorithm has no model of what a converting user looks like for your account. You will typically see either zero traffic (bids too conservative) or significant overspend on low-quality clicks (bids too aggressive). Give the algorithm data before handing it the wheel.

What about Enhanced CPC?

Enhanced CPC (eCPC) was retired for Search and Display campaigns in 2025 and is no longer a recommended transition step. The current ladder runs directly from Manual CPC to Maximize Conversions. If you encounter legacy documentation recommending eCPC, it no longer applies to new or active campaigns.

When should you switch to Smart Bidding?

Switch to Maximize Conversions once your campaign is generating at least 20–30 conversions per month at the campaign level — below that threshold, the algorithm is interpolating on thin data and results are unpredictable. [2]

Before making that switch, verify that conversion tracking is live, correctly attributed, and passing the right signals. [3] Micro-conversions — page views, scroll depth, time on site — should be set to Secondary action optimization in Google Ads so they inform your reporting without distorting Smart Bidding targets. Navigate to Goals & Conversions, open each micro-conversion action, and change its optimization setting to Secondary.

Best Practice: Set micro-conversions to "Secondary" conversion actions so they appear in your data without influencing bid decisions. This preserves observational insight without diluting your primary bidding signal. [3]

Run Maximize Conversions for a full 4–6 weeks before drawing conclusions or introducing a Target CPA. Resist the urge to make manual bid adjustments during this period — doing so interferes with the algorithm's learning and can restart the learning period entirely.

How does adding a Target CPA change how the campaign bids?

Adding a Target CPA tells Maximize Conversions to pursue conversions while averaging toward a specific cost-per-conversion goal across auctions — it is not a hard per-conversion cap. [4] The algorithm will spend above and below that figure in individual auctions and average toward your target over time. If you need a hard spend ceiling, that is a daily budget decision, not a bidding strategy decision. [5]

How to set your initial Target CPA without starving the campaign

  1. Calculate your average CPA over the last 30 days from Maximize Conversions.
  2. Set your initial Target CPA at 100–110% of that figure.
  3. Reduce by 5–10% every 2–3 weeks as performance stabilizes.
  4. Stop reducing when conversion volume begins to drop to an unacceptable level.

In accounts I manage, entering an aspirational target well below observed CPA — say, targeting $50 when actual CPA has been $85 — consistently collapses impression share without producing the efficiency gain practitioners hope for. Start conservative, then work down systematically. For more context on how different bidding strategies interact with campaign goals, the full topic archive covers related scenarios.

Key Insight: Target CPA is a target, not a ceiling. Google will sometimes bid above and below it in individual auctions while averaging toward your goal over time. [4]

When does it make sense to use Target ROAS instead of Target CPA?

Use Maximize Conversion Value with a Target ROAS for ecommerce or any setup where you are passing revenue values back to Google — it optimizes for revenue return rather than conversion count. [6] Google officially recommends at least 50 conversions with revenue data in the past 30 days before activating Target ROAS; in practice, for accounts with significant seasonal swings or wide product price variation, 75–100 conversions per month produces more stable results.

As with Target CPA, set your initial Target ROAS near your observed average ROAS, not your aspirational figure. If your account has been delivering 320% ROAS on Maximize Conversion Value, entering 600% as your target will likely collapse traffic volume significantly.

Strategy Best For Minimum Conversion Data Revenue Values Required
Manual CPC New campaigns, data gathering, low-budget accounts None No
Maximize Clicks Traffic-first goals, brand awareness None No
Maximize Conversions Scaling campaigns with moderate conversion volume 20–30/month No
Maximize Conversions + Target CPA Established campaigns with consistent CPA data 50+/month recommended No
Maximize Conversion Value Ecommerce, value-based optimization 30–50+/month Yes
Maximize Conversion Value + Target ROAS Ecommerce with revenue optimization targets 50+/month Yes

What bidding strategies work for edge cases — B2B, seasonal, and brand campaigns?

Standard Smart Bidding recommendations break down in several common scenarios that require a different approach.

Low-volume B2B campaigns

B2B accounts generating fewer than 20 conversions per month are difficult to automate effectively, often indefinitely. Manual CPC is frequently the most reliable long-term approach. If you need to build conversion volume to become Smart Bidding eligible, consider expanding your tracked conversion actions to include demo requests, qualified form submissions, and phone calls together — provided each action represents genuine business value. For more on bidding approaches on high-ticket, low-volume accounts, the considerations are similar.

Seasonal businesses

For businesses with sharp seasonal peaks — tax preparation, holiday retail, HVAC — Smart Bidding can struggle at the edges of seasons when historical conversion patterns shift rapidly. During ramp-up periods, temporarily removing your Target CPA or ROAS and reverting to unconstrained Maximize Conversions lets the algorithm adapt. Reintroduce targets once the season stabilizes and new patterns are established.

Brand vs. non-brand campaigns

Brand campaigns almost always convert at dramatically higher rates and lower CPAs than non-brand campaigns. Running them together under a single bidding strategy distorts performance for both. Separating brand and non-brand into distinct campaigns with separate bidding strategies and targets is one of the highest-impact structural decisions in any account.

Common Mistake: Running brand and non-brand keywords in the same campaign under Target CPA. Brand terms typically convert at 2–5x the rate of non-brand terms. This inflates your observed CPA baseline and causes the algorithm to underbid systematically on non-brand traffic. Always separate them structurally.

Portfolio bid strategies for low-volume accounts

If you manage multiple campaigns targeting similar audiences or products, Portfolio Bid Strategies let you pool conversion data across campaigns. Three campaigns each generating 20 conversions per month behave much like a single campaign with 60 — enough to run Target CPA reliably. Access portfolio strategies through Tools & Settings > Bid Strategies. This approach is frequently underused and can unlock Smart Bidding eligibility without waiting for any single campaign to reach threshold independently. For related structural approaches, see recommended bidding strategy combinations across different account setups.

How do you manage the learning period without disrupting performance?

Every bidding strategy switch — or Target CPA change exceeding 15–20% — triggers a learning period during which performance often deteriorates before recovering. [2] This period typically lasts 1–2 weeks, and up to 4 weeks for lower-volume campaigns.

If you want to test a strategy change without full exposure risk, running a campaign experiment before committing the full campaign is a lower-risk approach. [7]

What to do next

  1. Audit your conversion tracking. Verify that primary conversion actions are firing correctly, revenue values are passing through for ecommerce accounts, and micro-conversions are set to Secondary — not influencing bids.
  2. Match your strategy to your current data maturity. Fewer than 20 conversions per month: stay on Manual CPC or Maximize Clicks. Do not force Smart Bidding before the signal is there.
  3. Transition to Maximize Conversions at 20–30 monthly conversions and run it for a full 4–6 weeks before evaluating CPA or introducing a target.
  4. Introduce Target CPA or Target ROAS conservatively — start at or above your observed average, document the change date, and reduce targets gradually in 5–10% increments every 2–3 weeks.
  5. Separate brand from non-brand immediately if you have not already done so — this is the single highest-impact structural change available regardless of which bidding strategy you are running.

Frequently asked questions

Can I run Maximize Conversions with no conversion data at all?

Technically yes, but practically it produces poor results. Without conversion history, Maximize Conversions has no model of what a converting user looks like and will allocate budget based on generic signals. In accounts I manage, campaigns launched on Maximize Conversions with zero prior conversions consistently underperform compared to starting on Manual CPC and transitioning once 20–30 conversions per month are established.

How long should I wait before concluding a bidding strategy isn't working?

Allow at least 4–6 weeks after the learning period ends before drawing conclusions — not from the date of the switch, but from when the "Learning" label disappears in your campaign status. Evaluating performance during the learning period produces misleading data. For lower-volume campaigns, the full evaluation window can extend to 8 weeks before results are statistically meaningful.

Does a higher Target CPA always mean more conversions?

Generally yes — a more generous Target CPA gives the algorithm room to bid competitively in more auctions, which typically increases conversion volume. However, there is a point of diminishing returns where additional budget captures increasingly lower-quality conversions. The right Target CPA balances volume against your acceptable cost ceiling, not simply your desire to maximize conversion count.

What happens if I change my Target CPA too aggressively?

Dropping your Target CPA by more than 15–20% at once typically triggers a full reset of the learning period and can collapse impression share significantly. The algorithm needs time to find inventory that meets a tighter cost constraint. Reduce targets in 5–10% increments every 2–3 weeks, pausing reductions when conversion volume starts to fall to an unacceptable level. [4]

Is Portfolio Bidding available for all campaign types?

Portfolio bid strategies are available for Search campaigns and can be a highly effective tool for pooling conversion signals across campaigns that individually fall below Smart Bidding data thresholds. They are not available across campaign types — you cannot pool Search and Performance Max campaigns into the same portfolio strategy. Access them through Tools & Settings > Bid Strategies in your Google Ads account.

Should I use the same bidding strategy for Performance Max and Search campaigns?

Performance Max campaigns run on Maximize Conversions or Maximize Conversion Value by design — you cannot apply Manual CPC or Maximize Clicks to them. For Search campaigns running alongside Performance Max, keep them on separate bidding strategies with separate targets. Performance Max and Search campaigns often compete for similar queries, and blending their performance data under shared targets obscures what is actually driving results in each channel.

References

  1. Google Ads Help. “Determine a bid strategy based on your goals.” Accessed Nov 15, 2026.
  2. Google Ads Help. “About Smart Bidding.” Accessed Nov 15, 2026.
  3. Google Ads Help. “About conversion measurement.” Accessed Nov 15, 2026.
  4. Google Ads Help. “About Target CPA bidding.” Accessed Nov 15, 2026.
  5. Google Ads Help. “About average daily budgets.” Accessed Nov 15, 2026.
  6. Google Ads Help. “About Target ROAS bidding.” Accessed Nov 15, 2026.
  7. Google Ads Help. “Set up a custom experiment.” Accessed Nov 15, 2026.
  8. Original community discussion: r/PPC thread on Reddit.

Related Reading

AI Disclosure: This article was generated with AI assistance based on a community discussion on Reddit r/PPC. Expert analysis and practitioner perspective by John Williams, Founder, AHMEEGO · Google Ads Practitioner with $350M+ in managed Google Ads spend. AI was used to draft and structure the content; all strategic recommendations reflect real campaign experience.